CO2地质利用与封存环境下井筒完整性评估方法与保障策略Wellbore integrity assessment methods and integrity assurance strategies in CO2 geological utilization and storage environments
谭永胜,张力为,骆汀汀,李琦,李小春,呼布钦,刘桂臻,王翰文
摘要(Abstract):
在全球气候变化的严峻挑战下,CO_2捕集、利用与封存(CCUS)技术作为减少温室气体排放的重要手段,受到了广泛关注.在CCUS技术中,CO_2地质利用与封存是规模化消纳CO_2的关键环节.井筒作为封存CO_2可能发生逃逸的主要通道,其完整性对于确保封存过程的安全性和长期有效性至关重要.因此,研究CO_2封存过程井筒完整性问题,对于CO_2安全高效封存具有重要意义.在CO_2地质利用与封存环境下,井筒封隔密封性和井筒力学稳定性是决定CO_2封存安全的2个重要方面,需要重点关注.评估井筒封隔密封性建议采用泄漏风险识别—排序—评价的“三步走”评估方法,基于评估结果制定对应的泄漏风险监测和处置方案.评估井筒力学稳定性需建立CO_2注入井筒温度压力分布模型,然后考虑温度效应、鼓胀效应、活塞效应、管柱屈曲行为,建立管柱力学数学模型,计算油管和套管柱的力学完整性. CO_2封存环境下的油管、套管、固井水泥环腐蚀破坏是诱发井筒完整性失效的重要因素,钢材的显微组织、钢材的化学成分、固井水泥环的化学成分、初始固井质量、环境条件等均会影响腐蚀程度.为保障CO_2地质利用与封存环境下的井筒完整性,需深入研究井筒材料性能、优化井筒结构设计,并制定严格的监测和维护方案.
关键词(KeyWords): CO_2地质封存;井筒完整性;泄漏风险;腐蚀;力学失稳;风险监测
基金项目(Foundation): 国家重点研发计划战略性科技创新合作重点专项(2024YFE0213300);; 深地工程智能建造与健康运维全国重点实验室开放基金(SDGZ2502);; 中国科学院国际伙伴计划项目(026GJHZ2024018MI)
作者(Author): 谭永胜,张力为,骆汀汀,李琦,李小春,呼布钦,刘桂臻,王翰文
DOI: 10.13247/j.cnki.jcumt.20250545
参考文献(References):
- [1]黄晶.中国碳捕集利用与封存技术评估报告[R].北京:科学出版社,2021.Huang Jing. National assessment report on development of carbon capture utilization and storage technology in China[R]. Beijing:Science Press, 2021.
- [2]中国21世纪议程管理中心.中国二氧化碳捕集利用与封存(CCUS)年度报告(2023)[R].北京:中国21世纪议程管理中心,2023.The Administrative Center for China’s Agenda 21.China carbon dioxide capture, utilization, and storage(CCUS)annual report(2023)[R]. Beijing:The Administrative Center for China’s Agenda 21, 2023.
- [3]李怀展,唐超,郭广礼,等.超临界CO2对气化燃空区盖层烧变页岩力学性质影响规律研究[J].中国矿业大学学报,2025, 54(2):385-398.Li Huaizhan, Tang Chao, Guo Guangli, et al. Impact of supercritical CO2 on mechanical properties of burnt shale in overlying strata of gasification combustion zone[J]. Journal of China University of Mining&Technology, 2025, 54(2):385-398.
- [4]王新,杨鹏飞,梁冰,等.基于改进均质模型的深部咸水层CO2封存热-流-力耦合效应研究[J].中国矿业大学学报,2025, 54(2):399-412.Wang Xin, Yang Pengfei, Liang Bing, et al. Study on thermo-hydro-mechanical coupling effects of CO2sequestration in deep saline aquifers based on an improved homogeneous model[J]. Journal of China University of Mining&Technology, 2025, 54(2):399-412.
- [5]Colorado Geological Survey. CO2 sequestration[EB/OL].[2025-4-25]. https://coloradogeologicalsurvey.org/energy/e-CO2/.
- [6]刘兰翠,李琦.美国关于二氧化碳地质封存井的要求[J].低碳世界,2013,20(1):42-52.Liu Lancui, Li Qi. The requirements of the United States for geological carbon dioxide storage wells[J].Low Carbon World,2013,20(1):42-52.
- [7]李琦,宋然然,匡冬琴,等.二氧化碳地质封存与利用工程废弃井技术的现状与进展[J].地球科学进展,2016,31(3):225-235.Li Qi,Song Ranran,Kuang Dongqin,et al. Status and advances of abandoned process of wells for CO2 geological storage[J]. Advances in Earth Science,2016,31(3):225-235.
- [8]谭永胜,庞照宇,李琦,等.海上老井井筒完整性失效机制及二氧化碳注入可行性研究进展[J].环境工程学报,2024,18(10):2754-2763.Tan Yongsheng,Pan Zhaoyu,Li Qi,et al. Research progress on mechanism of wellbore integrity failure and feasibility of CO2 injection for existing wells of offshore CO2 geological storage[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering, 2024, 18(10):2754-2763.
- [9]NORSOK Standard D-010:Well Integrity in drilling and well operations,Rev.4[S].
- [10]张绍槐.井筒完整性的定义、功能、应用及进展[J].石油钻采工艺,2018,40(1):1-8.Zhang Shaohuai. Definition,function,application and progress of wellbore integrity[J]. Oil Drilling&Production Technology,2018,40(1):1-8.
- [11]李琦,石晖,杨多兴.碳封存项目井喷CO2扩散危险水平分级方法研究[J].岩土力学,2016,37(7):2070-2078.Li Qi, Shi Hui, Yang Duoxing. Classification of hazard levels of carbon dioxide dispersion under a well blowout in a CCS project[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics,2016,37(7):2070-2078.
- [12]Li Q,Liu X H,Zhang J,et al. A novel shallow well monitoring system for CCUS:With application to Shengli oilfield CO2-EOR project[J]. Energy Procedia,2014,63:3956-3962.
- [13]Li Q,Li X Y,Kuang D Q,et al. Abandonment process for injection well of China’s Shenhua carbon dioxide geological storage demonstration project[J].Greenhouse Gases:Science and Technology,2017,7(5):903-914.
- [14]刘学浩,李琦,方志明,等.一种新型浅层井CO2监测系统的研发[J].岩土力学,2015,36(3):898-904.Liu Xuehao,Li Qi,Fang Zhiming,et al. A novel CO2monitoring system in shallow well[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics,2015,36(3):898-904.
- [15]Digiulio D. Evaluation of draft environmental impact report on geological storage of carbon dioxide at the Carbon Terra Vault I Facility in Kern County, California[R]. EPA Report EPA-R09-OW-2023-0623-0088,2024.
- [16]Pressley M. EPA announces proposed order requiring Archer Daniels Midland Co. to take actions to ensure safe operation of its carbon sequestration well in Decatur, Illinois[EB/OL].[2026-6-3]. https://www. epa. gov/newsreleases/epa-announcesproposed-order-requiring-archer-daniels-midland-cotake-actions-ensure.
- [17]李军,吴继伟,谢士远,等.吉木萨尔页岩油井筒完整性失效特点与控制方法[J].新疆石油天然气,2021,17(3):37-43.Li Jun,Wu Jiwei,Xie Shiyuan,et al. Characteristics and control methods of wellbore integrity failure for Jimsar Shale Oil[J]. Xinjiang Oil&Gas,2021,17(3):37-43.
- [18]唐浩瑞.南海西部XX井井筒完整性风险分析[J].中国石油和化工标准与质量,2023,43(4):70-72.Tang Haorui. Wellbore integrity risk analysis of Well XX in the Western South China Sea[J]. China Petroleum and Chemical Standard and Quality,2023,43(4):70-72.
- [19]田园.在役油气井井筒完整性研究[J].现代职业安全,2025(1):63-65.Tian Yuan. Research on wellbore integrity of in-service oil and gas wells[J]. Modern Occupational Safety,2025(1):63-65.
- [20]Yousuf N,Olayiwola O,Guo B,et al. A comprehensive review on the loss of wellbore integrity due to cement failure and available remedial methods[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2021,207:109123.
- [21]Kiran R, Teodoriu C, Dadmohammadi Y, et al.Identification and evaluation of well integrity and causes of failure of well integrity barriers(A review)[J]. Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2017, 45:511-526.
- [22]李琦,井淼. CO2注入引起的井筒周围岩石损伤的热孔弹耦合分析[J].岩石力学与工程学报,2013,32(11):2205-2213.Li Qi, Jing Miao. Thermo-poroelastic coupling analysis of rock damagearound wellbore due to CO2 injection[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,2013,32(11):2205-2213.
- [23]Tan Y S,Li H T,Li Q,et al. Experimental evaluation method for acid injection profiles of horizontal wells during a carbonate acidizing process[J]. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2020,192:107245.
- [24]He M,Li Q,Li X Y,et al. Traffic light system regulation of induced seismicity under multi-well fluid injection[J]. Energy Geoscience,2025,6(2):100368.
- [25]时维才,姚峰,金勇,等.二氧化碳驱注采井管柱失效原因分析及防护对策[J].石油管材与仪器,2021,7(6):74-78.Shi Weicai,Yao Feng,Jin Yong,et al. Failure cause analysis and protection countermeasures of downhole string in the CO2 injection and production wells[J].Petroleum Tubular Goods&Instruments,2021,7(6):74-78.
- [26]孟凡娟,王清,李慧心,等. 3Cr钢在油水两相层流工况下的腐蚀行为[J].工程科学学报,2020,42(8):1029-1039.Meng Fanjuan,Wang Qing,Li Huixin,et al. Corrosion behavior for 3Cr steel under oil-water two-phase laminar flow conditions[J]. Chinese Journal of Engineering,2020,42(8):1029-1039.
- [27]Hu Z Y,Duan D L,Hou S H,et al. Preliminary study on corrosion behaviour of carbon steel in oil-water two-phase fluids[J]. Journal of Materials Science&Technology,2015,31(12):1274-1281.
- [28]夏晓健,万芯媛,陈云翔,等.两种热处理工艺对3Cr钢腐蚀行为影响及机理研究[J].中国腐蚀与防护学报,2023,43(3):656-662.Xia Xiaojian,Wan Xinyuan,Chen Yunxiang,et al. Effect of heat treatments on corrosion behavior of 3Cr low carbon steel[J]. Journal of Chinese Society for Corrosion and Protection,2023,43(3):656-662.
- [29]Xu L N, Wang B, Zhu J Y, et al. Effect of Cr content on the corrosion performance of low-Cr alloy steel in a CO2 environment[J]. Applied Surface Science,2016,379:39-46.
- [30]Wang H W, Zhang L W, Gan M G, et al. Temperature and reaction time’s effects on N80 steel corrosion behavior in supercritical CO 2 and formation water environments[J]. Applied Sciences, 2024, 14(2):728.
- [31]Sun W,Pugh D V,Smith S N,et al. A parametric study of sour corrosion of carbon steel[C]//Proceedings of the CORROSION 2010. San Antonio:AMPP, 2010:1-20.
- [32]潘代龙,司晓东,吕金洪.流速对碳钢弯管段流动加速腐蚀速率的影响[J].中国腐蚀与防护学报,2023,43(5):1064-1070.Pan Dailong,Si Xiaodong,Lyu Jinhong. Effect of flow velocity on flow accelerated corrosion rate of carbon steel elbow[J]. Journal of Chinese Society for Corrosion and Protection,2023,43(5):1064-1070.
- [33]Xiang Y,Li C,Hesitao W,et al. Understanding the pitting corrosion mechanism of pipeline steel in an impure supercritical CO2 environment[J]. The Journal of Supercritical Fluids,2018,138:132-142.
- [34]万仁溥.现代完井工程(第三版)[M].北京:石油工业出版社,2008.Wan Renpu. Advanced well completion engineering[M]. Beijing:Petroleum Industry Press, 2008.
- [35]王吉连,熊金平,唐聿明,等.氯离子浓度和温度对Cr3钢CO2/H2S腐蚀的影响[J].腐蚀与防护,2010,31(12):913-916.Wang Jilian,Xiong Jinping,Tang Yuming,et al. Effects of Cl-concentration and temperature on corrosion of Cr3 steel in CO2/H2S environment[J]. Corrosion&Protection,2010,31(12):913-916.
- [36]Gan M G,Zhang L W,Wang Y,et al. Experimental study on the corrosion behavior of wellbore cement with a leaking channel under different acidic environments[J]. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2024,139:104267.
- [37]Mei K Y,Zhang L W,Cai Y N,et al. Investigation of chemical processes in cement exposed to wet ScCO2and CO2-saturated brine in geological CO2 storage conditions[J]. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2024,135:104143.
- [38]姚晓.二氧化碳对油井水泥石的腐蚀及其防护措施[J].钻井液与完井液,1998, 15(1):8-12.Yao Xiao. Carbon dioxide corrosion in oilwell cement and its prevention measures[J]. Drilling Fluid&Completion Fluid, 1998, 15(1):8-12.
- [39]郑怡杰,龚鹏,邓卓然,等.镁橄榄石对油井水泥抗CO2腐蚀性能的影响[J].中国粉体技术,2024,30(2):151-163.Zheng Yijie, Gong Peng, Deng Zhuoran, et al. Effect of magnesium olivine on CO2 corrosion resistance of oil well cement[J]. China Powder Science and Technology, 2024, 30(2):151-163.
- [40]田进.羟基磷灰石耐高温抗CO2腐蚀水泥浆[J].钻井液与完井液,2022, 39(2):208-213.Tian Jin. A high temperature CO2 resistant hydroxyapatite cement slurry[J]. Drilling Fluid&Completion Fluid, 2022, 39(2):208-213.
- [41]刘思楠,张力为,甘满光,等.地质封存环境CO2压力影响水泥碳化程度的试验研究[J].中国电机工程学报,2022,42(9):3126-3135.Liu Sinan, Zhang Liwei, Gan Manguang, et al. experimental study of the effect of CO2 pressure on the degree of cement carbonation under geologic CO2storage environment[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE,2022, 42(9):3126-3135.
- [42]余杨,黄文,姚广等.二氧化碳腐蚀作用下固井水泥石的微观力学性能[J].混凝土世界,2024(3):68-73.Yu Yang, Huang Wen, Yao Guang, et al. Microscopic mechanical properties of cementing cement paste under carbon dioxide corrosion[J]. China Concrete, 2024(3):68-73.
- [43]饶志华,张伟国,邓成辉,等.浅层大位移CO2回注井固井防腐水泥浆体系构建与工程应用[J].中国海上油气,2025, 37(3):187-193.Rao Zhihua, Zhang Weiguo, Deng Chenghui, et al.Construction and engineering application of corrosion-resistant cement slurry system for shallow extended-reach CO2 injection well cementing[J].China Offshore Oil and Gas, 2025, 37(3):187-193.
- [44]郝锋,张宗峰,王宏民,等. CO2地质封存注入井固井水泥:腐蚀机理、改性与应用研究进展[J].煤田地质与勘探,2026, 54(1):1-10.Hao Feng, Zhang Zongfeng, Wang Hongmin, et al.Advances in research on CO2 corrosion mechanisms,modification, and application of cements for injection wells in geologic CO2 sequestration[J]. Coal Geology&Exploration, 2026, 54(1):1-10.
- [45]Saint-marc J,Garnier A,Bois A P. Initial state of stress:The key to achieving long-term cement-sheath integrity[C]//SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition. Denver, 2008:SPE-116651-MS.
- [46]Kalousek G L. The reactions of cement hydration at elevated temperatures[C]//Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on the Chemistry of Cement. London:ICE Publishing, 1952:334-355.
- [47]Nelson E, Eilers L. Cementing steamflood and fireflood wells-slurry design[J]. Journal of Canadian Petroleum Technology,1985,24(5):PETSOC-85-05-06.
- [48]Feng Y C,Yan W,Zhang L W,et al. Corrosion in CO2 geological utilization and storage. In:Zhang, L.(Editor). Corrosion in CO2 capture, Transportation,Geological Utilization and Storage[M]. Singapore:Springer,2023.
- [49]Su X B,Liu S N,Zhang L W,et al. Wellbore leakage risk management under CGUS conditions:A review[J]. Energy Reviews,2023,2(4):100049.
- [50]甘满光,雷宏武,张力为,等.基于数值模拟的CO2地质封存项目井筒泄漏风险定量化评价方法[J].工程科学与技术,2024,56(1):195-205.Gan Manguang,Lei Hongwu,Zhang Liwei,et al.Quantitative evaluation method of wellbore leakage risk of CO2 geological storage project based on numerical simulation[J]. Advanced Engineering Sciences,2024,56(1):195-205.
- [51]T-CSES 71—2022二氧化碳地质利用与封存项目泄漏风险评价规范[S].T-CSES 71—2022 The specification on risk assessment of the leakage for the projects of CO2 geological utilization and storage[S].
- [52]Shi H,Holmes J A,Durlofsky L J,et al. Drift-flux modeling of two-phase flow in wellbores[J]. SPE Journal,2005,10(1):24-33.
- [53]高德利,黄文君.井下管柱力学与控制方法若干研究进展[J].力学进展,2021, 51(3):620-647.Gao Deli, Huang Wenjun. Some research advances in downhole tubular mechanics and control methods[J]. Advances in Mechanics, 2021, 51(3):620-647.
- [54]Lubinski A. Developments in petroleum engineering vol. 1:Stability of tubulars and deviation control[M].Houston:Gulf Publishing Company,1988.
- [55]刘铭刚.基于Euler管流模型和多层界面模型的UGS井筒力学分析及完整性评价方法研究[D].青岛:中国石油大学(华东),2018.Liu Minggang. Study on mechanical analysis method and integrity evaluation process of UGS wellbore based on Euler gas-flow model and multilayered model[D]. Qingdao:China University of Petroleum(Huadong),2018.
- [56]朱良松.二氧化碳注入过程井筒力学完整性研究[D].北京:中国石油大学(北京),2020.Zhu Liangsong. Research on wellbore mechanical integrity during carbon dioxide injection[D]. Beijing:China University of Petroleum(Beijing), 2020.
- [57]马昭旭.非稳态二氧化碳注入过程井筒力学完整性研究[D].北京:中国石油大学(北京),2024.Ma Zhaoxu. Research on wellbore mechanical integrity during unsteady carbon dioxide injection[D]. Beijing:China University of Petroleum(Beijing), 2024
- [58]Zinkham R E,Goodwin R J. Burst resistance of pipe cemented into the earth[J]. Journal of Petroleum Technology,1962,14(9):1033-1040.
- [59]李军,陈勉,柳贡慧,等.套管、水泥环及井壁围岩组合体的弹塑性分析[J].石油学报,2005(6):99-103.Li Jun, Chen Mian, Liu Gonghui, et al. Elasticplastic analysis of casing-concrete sheath-rock combination[J]. Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2005(6):99-103.
- [60]ISO 16530-1:2017 Petroleum and natural gas industries:Well integrity:Part 1:Life cycle governance[S].
- [61]NORSOK D-010:2021 Well integrity in drilling and well operations", revision 5[S].
- [62]API RP 90-2:2016 Annular casing pressure management for onshore wells[S].
- [63]Techlog wellbore integrity[EB/OL].[2026-6-3].https:www. slb. com/zh-cn/products-and-service/delivering-digital-at-scale/software/teclog-wellboresoftware/techlog/techlog-production/techlog
- [64]基于ABAQUS的井完整性仿真分析技术[EB/OL].[2026-6-3]. https:www. think-s. com/CAE?article_id=1917Well integrity simulation analysis technology based on ABAQUS[EB/OL].[2026-6-3]. https:www.think-s.com/CAE?article_id=1917
- [65]赵帅.基于ABAQUS的超深井固井水泥环完整性分析[J].石油和化工设备,2025, 28(6):142-145.Zhao Shuai. ABAQUS-based integrity analysis of cement sheath in ultra-deep well cementing[J]. Journal of Petroleum and Chemical Equipment, 2025, 28(6):142-145.
- [66]刘建新,魏伟,韩博,等.四丙氟橡胶和氢化丁腈橡胶的耐CO2腐蚀性能[J].腐蚀与防护,2017,38(9):702-704.Liu Jianxin, Wei Wei, Han Bo,et al. CO2 corrosion resistance of tetrapropyl fluoro rubber and hydrogenated nitrile butadiene rubber[J]. Corrosion&Protection, 2017, 38(9):702-704.
- [67]唐泽玮,姚斌,姬振宁,等.非晶态镍钨合金镀层油管的耐CO2腐蚀性能[J].腐蚀与防护,2020,41(10):12-17.Tang Zewei,Yao Bin,Ji Zhenning,et al. CO2 corrosion resistance of amorphous nickel-tungsten alloy coated tubing[J]. Corrosion&Protection,2020,41(10):12-17.
- [68]胡鹏斌,李成科,乔玉山,等.聚合物凝胶堵漏材料在石油工程中的应用研究进展[J].广州化工,2024,52(14):14-16.Hu Pengbin,Li Chengke,Qiao Yushan,et al. Research progress on application of polymer gel plugging materials in petroleum engineering[J]. Guangzhou Chemical Industry,2024,52(14):14-16.
- [69]Mei K Y, Zhang L W, Wang Y, et al. Structural evolution in micro-calcite bearing Ca-montmorillonite reinforced oilwell cement during CO2 invasion[J].Construction and Building Materials,2022,315:125744.