早强与延性组分对封孔材料性能作用机理及熵权-TOPSIS法组分优选Effect mechanism of early strength and ductility components on properties of sealing materials and composition optimization by entropy weight-TOPSIS method
冯国瑞,张靖,李振,张艺蝶,高亮,王江漫,贺婷立,王柱
摘要(Abstract):
在瓦斯抽采过程中,松软煤层封孔段极易遇到钻孔变形引起塌孔的现象,制约瓦斯高效抽采.因此,本文以水泥-粉煤灰为基体,分别掺入早强组分:硫酸钠(SS)、三乙醇胺(TEA)、纳米二氧化硅(SiO_2),以及延性组分(多尺度纤维):聚乙烯醇纤维(PVAF)、微晶纤维素(MCC)、纳米纤维素(CNFs),进行了早强及延性性能调控,揭示了不同组分对水泥基封孔材料性能作用机理,并基于熵权-逼近理想解排序法(熵权-TOPSIS法)实现了材料组分优选.结果表明:外加组分的掺入在降低浆液流动性的同时增加其稳定性.早强组分在水化进程中均发挥促凝作用,SS通过提供SO_4~(2-)提高浆液碱度,加速钙矾石生成,养护1 d强度提升明显;TEA通过与Ca~(2+)络合持续促进水化,强度随龄期增加呈线性增长;SiO_2通过成核与微集料效应优化孔隙结构,强度增速减缓,28 d抗压强度和劈裂抗拉强度分别达到52.62和3.81 MPa.延性组分均通过桥接与裂纹偏转机制改善材料延性,不同尺度延性组分表现出差异化的增强规律. PVAF(毫米级)组试件在早期出现延性下降,但28 d时延性显著提升13.7%;MCC(微米级)组在1和28 d时延性保持较高水平,3和7 d时出现阶段性下降;而CNFs(纳米级)组试件在4个龄期延性分别优于对照组4.4%,4.0%,2.1%,5.2%,体现出持续稳定的增强效果.基于熵权-TOPSIS法建立了浆液工作性能和不同龄期固结体强度多指标综合评价体系,通过科学赋权与综合寻优,确定SiO_2和CNFs分别是早强和延性组分的最优选择,为后续单因素及响应面试验优化最佳配比提供了科学依据.
关键词(KeyWords): 封孔材料;水泥-粉煤灰基体;早强组分;延性组分;熵权-TOPSIS法
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金面上项目(52474141);国家自然科学基金青年科学基金项目(A类延续资助)(52525401);; 山西省基础研究计划项目(202403021211069)
作者(Author): 冯国瑞,张靖,李振,张艺蝶,高亮,王江漫,贺婷立,王柱
DOI: 10.13247/j.cnki.jcumt.20250620
参考文献(References):
- [1]王双明,申艳军,宋世杰,等.“双碳”目标下煤炭能源地位变化与绿色低碳开发[J].煤炭学报,2023,48(7):2599-2612.Wang Shuangming,Shen Yanjun,Song Shijie,et al.Change of coal energy status and green and low-carbon development under the"dual carbon"goal[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2023,48(7):2599-2612.
- [2]袁亮.我国煤炭主体能源安全高质量发展的理论技术思考[J].中国科学院院刊,2023,38(1):11-22.Yuan Liang. Theory and technology considerations on high-quality development of coal main energy security in China[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2023,38(1):11-22.
- [3]冯国瑞,崔业凯,李竹,等.矿山遗存地下空间利用现状与结构充填技术应用前景[J].绿色矿山,2025,3(2):1-14.Feng Guorui,Cui Yekai,Li Zhu,et al. Utilization status of underground space of mine remains and application prospect of structural filling technology[J]. Journal of Green Mine,2025,3(2):1-14.
- [4]Zhang E H,Zhou B K,Yang L,et al. Experimental study on the microseismic response characteristics of coal and gas outbursts[J]. Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2023,172:1058-1071.
- [5]刘一鸣,李振,冯国瑞,等.循环加卸载下裂隙砂岩声-热响应特征及前兆规律[J].岩土力学,2025,46(9):2773-2791.Liu Yiming, Li Zhen, Feng Guorui, et al.Acoustic-thermal response characteristics and precursor law of fissured sandstone under cyclic loading and unloading[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics,2025,46(9):2773-2791.
- [6]Jing M,Ni G H,Xu Y H,et al. Modeling and optimization of mechanical properties of drilling sealing materials based on response surface method[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production,2022,377:134452.
- [7]Li B,Jian W,Zhang J X,et al. Research progress and discussion on modified cement-based borehole sealing materials for mining[J]. Acs Omega,2023,8(15):13539-13550.
- [8]Cheng J W,Hou W H,Luo W,et al. Preferred ratio and properties of microfoam drilling fluid for gas extraction in soft coal seams[J]. Energy&Fuels,2024,38(11):9606-9623.
- [9]王建国,李培博,梁伟,等.薄互层煤系气单井压裂合采的岩石力学地层理论初探[J].中国矿业大学学报,2025,54(1):65-82.Wang Jianguo,Li Peibo,Liang Wei,et al. Preliminary study on rock mechanics stratigraphy theory for single well fracturing and coproduction from thin interbedded coal measure gas reservoirs[J]. Journal of China University of Mining&Technology,2025,54(1):65-82.
- [10]刘勇,张汶定,陈长江,等.松软煤层空气射流冲孔卸压关键技术研究与应用[J].煤炭学报,2025,50(11):4915-4927.Liu Yong,Zhang Wending,Chen Changjiang,et al.Research and application of key technologies for air jet drilling pressure relief in soft coal seams[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2025,50(11):4915-4927.
- [11]刘鹏,陈楠,聂百胜,等.松软强吸附煤层超声场激励瓦斯促抽机制及工程应用[J].中国矿业大学学报,2025,54(5):1020-1036.Liu Peng,Chen Nan,Nie Baisheng,et al. Power ultrasound-induced coal structure modification and desorption-diffusion kinetics evolution[J]. Journal of China University of Mining&Technology,2025,54(5):1020-1036.
- [12]Wang Q,Zhang Y J,Feng G R,et al. Research and application of the calculation method for vertical stress of interlayer rock in coal mining under pillar goaf[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering,2025,58(11):12447-12468.
- [13]李振,余奕睿,王红伟,等.承压破碎无烟煤气体渗透特性影响因素实验研究[J].煤田地质与勘探,2024,52(3):1-13.Li Zhen,Yu Yirui,Wang Hongwei,et al. An experimental study of factors influencing gas seepage in confined broken anthracite[J]. Coal Geology&Exploration,2024,52(3):1-13.
- [14]张吉雄,周楠,刘恒凤,等.煤基固废功能材料井下利用研究进展与展望[J].煤炭科学技术,2025,53(6):1-28.Zhang Jixiong,Zhou Nan,Liu Hengfeng,et al. Research progress and prospect of underground utilization of coal-based solid waste functional materials[J].Coal Science and Technology,2025,53(6):1-28.
- [15]Liu B J,Shi J Y,Liang H,et al. Synergistic enhancement of mechanical property of the high replacement low-calcium ultrafine fly ash blended cement paste by multiple chemical activators[J]. Journal of Building Engineering,2020,32:101520.
- [16]Wang Y L,Tang H Y,Su J X,et al. Effect of sodium sulfate and gypsum on performances of expansive grouting material with aluminum as expansion agent[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2023,394:132212.
- [17]Wang W C,Duong H T H,Huang W H,et al. The influence of temperatures on the hydration of cement paste at the early age, and behaviour of cement paste with the addition of triethanolamine(TEA)and triisopropanolamine(TIPA)[J]. Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology,2023,21(3):136-150.
- [18]Liu H,Lin H,Liu X Y,et al. Effects of triethanolamine on autogenous shrinkage and drying shrinkage of cement mortar[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2021,304:124620.
- [19]Wu Z H,Liu J Y,Zhang G L,et al. Effect of aluminum sulfate alkali-free liquid accelerator with compound alkanol lamine on the hydration processes of Portland cement[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2021,308:125101.
- [20]Bai S,Yu L B,Guan X C,et al. Comparative study on effects of pozzolanic nano-SiO2 and nonpozzolanic nano-TiO2 on the microstructure and macro properties of cement paste subjected to earlyage frost attack[J]. Cold Regions Science and Technology,2023,210:103841.
- [21]Zhao J L,Huang J J,Wang Z K,et al. Enhancing mechanical strength and reducing drying shrinkage in high-volume fly ash mortar:Synergistic effects of steel fibers and nano-SiO2[J]. Journal of Materials Research and Technology,2025,36:7351-7360.
- [22]石凯龙,杜常博,易富,等.渗透结晶型材料与纳米SiO2改性水泥浆液性能及防渗机制[J].复合材料学报,2025,42(8):4702-4715.Shi Kailong,Du Changbo,Yi Fu,et al. Permeable crystalline materials and nano-SiO2 modified cement grout performance and anti-seepage mechanism[J].Acta Materiae Compositae Sinica,2025,42(8):4702-4715.
- [23]Zhang Y J,Cui B Y,Feng G R,et al. Shear mechanical properties of loaded rock under drilling and dynamic load and its influence on the plastic zone of roadway[J]. International Journal of Mining Science and Technology,2025,35(7):1073-1091.
- [24]Yang K,Long G C,Tang Z,et al. Enhancement in strength and toughness of ultra-high performance concrete(UHPC)from micron-and nano-scale[J]. Journal of Building Engineering,2023,69:106308.
- [25]Yang K,Tang Z,Li W G,et al. A comprehensive review on the toughening technologies of cement-based materials:From multiscale materials to advanced processes[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2024,456:139274.
- [26]郭鑫,李大芳,鲁义,等. GO-PVA注浆材料的制备及其强度特征研究[J].安全与环境学报,2024,24(10):3827-3838.Guo Xin,Li Dafang,Lu Yi,et al. Preparation of GO-PVA grouting material and its strength characteristics study[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment,2024,24(10):3827-3838.
- [27]Lin C L,Wang S Y,Chen M,et al. Experimental study on the mechanical properties of different fiberreinforced seawater sea-sand engineered cementitious composites[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2021,304:124562.
- [28]Zheng S Z,Zhou H,Xu S F,et al. Synergistic enhancement of the mechanical properties of cementbased materials by using microcrystalline cellulose and nano-silica composites[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2024,411:134458.
- [29]Parveen S,Rana S,Ferreira S,et al. Ultrasonic dispersion of micro crystalline cellulose for developing cementitious composites with excellent strength and stiffness[J]. Industrial Crops and Products,2018,122:156-165.
- [30]Fan L,Wu C T,Tong Y Y,et al. Unraveling hybrid"Radical-Template"effect:Boosting early-age performance in hexagonal boron nitride/nanocellulose reinforced cement composites[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2025,503:144558.
- [31]Zhang Z D,Scherer G W,Measuring chemical shrinkage of ordinary Portland cement pastes with high water-to-cement ratios by adding cellulose nanofibrils[J]. Cement&Concrete Composites,2020,111:103625.
- [32]Haque M I,Ashraf W,Khan R I,et al. A comparative investigation on the effects of nanocellulose from bacteria and plant-based sources for cementitious composites[J]. Cement&Concrete Composites,2022,125:104316.
- [33]贺炯煌.早强水泥浆体微结构与性能演变特征及机理[D].长沙:中南大学,2022.He Jionghuang. Characteristics of microstructure and propertiesdevelopment of high early strength cement paste and itsmechanism[D]. Changsha:Central South University,2022.
- [34]Arain M F,Wang M X,Chen J Y,et al. Study on PVA fiber surface modification for strain-hardening cementitious composites(PVA-SHCC)[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2019,197:107-116.
- [35]Hisseine O A,Wilson W,Sorelli L,et al. Nanocellulose for improved concrete performance:A macro-tomicro investigation for disclosing the effects of cellulose filaments on strength of cement systems[J].Construction and Building Materials,2019,206:84-96.
- [36]冯国瑞,周鹏飞,杜献杰,等.螺旋箍筋直径对矸石胶结充填柱承载破坏特征的影响机理[J].中南大学学报(自然科学版),2025,56(10):4306-4320.Feng Guorui,Zhou Pengfei,Du Xianjie,et al. Influence mechanism of spiral stirrup diameter on the bearing failure characteristics of cemented gangue backfill columns[J]. Journal of Central South University(Science and Technology),2025,56(10):4306-4320.
- [37]Chen J X,Jia J Q,The effects of hardening accelerator on microstructure and mechanical performance of fly ash-cement-based materials using response surface methodology[J]. Journal of Building Engineering,2024,94:109984.
- [38]Chen Y H,Zeng X H,Zhang Y T,et al. Effects of nanomaterials on early-age properties and microstructure of calcium sulfoaluminate-Portland cementbased repair mortar under-10℃curing[J]. Case Studies in Construction Materials,2025,23:e05536.
- [39]Ma K,Deng H W,Guo X S,et al. The investigating on mechanical properties of engineered cementitious composites with high ductility and low cost[J]. Journal of Building Engineering,2022,57:104873.
- [40]马建宏,王琪,焦华喆,等.纤维聚合物柔韧混凝土微观孔隙结构特征与增强机理[J].中国矿业大学学报,2024,53(6):1157-1170.Ma Jianhong,Wang Qi,Jiao Huazhe,et al. Microscopic pore structure characteristics and strengthening mechanism of fiber polymer flexible concrete[J].Journal of China University of Mining&Technology,2024,53(6):1157-1170.
- [41]Leroux D,Olivès R,Neveu P. Combining entropy weight and TOPSIS method for selection of tank geometry and filler material of a packed-bed thermal energy storage system[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production,2023,414:137588.
- [42]李振,刘一鸣,冯国瑞,等.煤岩气固耦合损伤灾变可视化观测系统的研制及应用[J/OL].采矿与岩层控制学报,1-15[2026-01-25]. https://doi.org/10.13532/j.jmsce.cn10-1638/td.2025-1406.Li Zhen, Liu Yiming,Feng Guorui,et al. Development and application of visualized observation system for coal-rock gas-solid coupled damage catastrophe[J/OL]. Journal of Mining and Strata Control Engineering, 1-15[2026-01-25]. https://doi. org/10.13532/j.jmsce.cn10-1638/td.2025-1406.
- [43]李树刚,张静非,张超,等.新型CF封孔材料的膨胀作用机理及其关键影响因素实验研究[J].采矿与安全工程学报,2018,35(2):415-421.Li Shugang,Zhang Jingfei,Zhang Chao,et al. Experimental study on expansion mechanism of new CF sealing material and the key influencing factors[J].Journal of Mining&Safety Engineering,2018,35(2):415-421.
- [44]Cheng J W,Ran D Z,Fu Q,et al. Solid-liquid particle flow sealing mucus(PFSM)in enhancing coalbed methane(CBM)recovery:Multiple-perspectives analysis and mechanism insights[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2024,435:136670.
- [45]Pan X L,Wang Y,Kong D Z,et al. Development,optimisation and performance prediction of a novel cement-based materials for borehole sealing[J]. Construction and Building Materials,2025,478:141404.
- [46]Dong K,Ni G H,Nie B S,et al. Effect of polyvinyl alcohol/aluminum microcapsule expansion agent on porosity and strength of cement-based drilling sealing material[J]. Energy,2021,224:119966.
- [47]司磊磊,师伟峰,魏建平,等.基于自修复效应的封孔材料裂隙自愈合特性[J].煤炭学报,2023,48(11):4097-4111.Si Leilei,Shi Weifeng,Wei Jianping,et al. Selfhealing characteristics of fracture in sealing materials based on self-healing effect[J]. Journal of China Coal Society,2023,48(11):4097-4111.
- [48]张超,延婧,李树刚,等.瓦斯抽采钻孔动态密封黏液型材料实验研究[J].采矿与安全工程学报,2022,39(5):1033-1040.Zhang Chao,Yan Jing,Li Shugang,et al. Experimental study on dynamic sealing of mucilage material in gas extraction borehole[J]. Journal of Mining&Safety Engineering,2022,39(5):1033-1040.
- [49]翟成,向贤伟,余旭,等.瓦斯抽采钻孔柔性膏体封孔材料封孔性能研究[J].中国矿业大学学报,2013,42(6):982-988.Zhai Cheng,Xiang Xianwei,Yu Xu,et al. Sealing performance of flexible gel sealingmaterial of gas drainage borehole[J]. Journal of China University of Mining&Technology,2013,42(6):982-988.
- [50]李振,张汝萍,冯国瑞,等.复合改性自适应缓凝封孔材料研制与多目标性能协同优化[J].采矿与安全工程学报,2026,43(3):758-775.Li Zhen,Zhang Ruping,Feng Guorui,et al. Development of composite modified adaptive retarding sealing material and multi-objective performance collaborative optimization[J]. Journal of Mining&Safety Engineering,2026,43(3):758-775.